Sacked Nav – GPS devices lose their way as van drivers’ trust their own navigation

By John Simpson 10 August 2012

One in ten respondents had never used a sat nav at all, ever, in their whole life. One in five van drivers prefer to rely on their own navigation intuition than use a sat nav, according to a new survey which questions the reliability of the devices.

A third of the 1,000 van drivers that took part in high street insurance retailer Swinton’s poll said they have been taken to the wrong destination by their mischievous, or more likely, incompetent sat nav.

Over two fifths of van drivers regarded their own navigational skills as 'excellent' but almost half keep a map handy “just in case”.

One in ten respondents claim they have never used a sat nav at all, ever, in their whole life.

Waste of fuel, waste of money

This sat nav (in a Toyota Hiace) looks particularly sorry for itself.When asked to explain why they shun GPS devices, some were concerned it could make a driver late for a job and waste petrol and money by giving inaccurate directions.

Phil Moss, Commercial Vehicle Manager at Swinton Van Insurance, appreciated that many drivers still trusted their own navigational instinct rather than blindly obeying and conforming to technology.

He said: “The impact on a business should a sat nav go wrong, can manifest itself in a number of ways - damaging customer relations as well as having financial implications should it interfere with trading.

"Whilst many people use sat navs, some simply trust their own skills more - perhaps having been brought up in the area or knowing short-cuts that their device may not be programmed for.

“It is also important to remember to update your sat nav regularly, ensuring that any new roads, speed cameras or closures are included."

A similar survey from the start of the year found that a fifth of motorists would rather turn to their smartphone for directions rather than their sat nav while a third admitted they never use their sat nav anymore.

In March 2012, local transport minister Norman Baker led the Government’s first ever sat nav summit in a bid to wipe out outdated directions given by sat-nav devices after frequent incidents of lorries and other large vehicles taking unsuitable routes and getting stuck.


Categories: Fleet news

More miles for your money – Trading Standards complaints backfire on motorists Honda commended for Motability service, full list of awards winners revealed

See Also

Leave a Comment...

Fleet Voice Column

Gearboxes are an indicator of how far we’ve come

If you ever need an example of how far the car and automotive technology has come in a single generation, just reach for the gear lever in your car. A mere 25 years ago, you would most likely have the choice of five gears…

Why LPG could play a huge part in driving the future of our fleets

There are a great many considerations to take into account when looking at your next company car. Some are purely financial and others will be environmental, either because of monetary reasons or because of your conscience.…

How the latest batch of hot hatches are heating up motoring for the business driver

Hot hatches have been through a few ups and downs in the time the class has properly existed. From must-have 1980s accessory to untouchable, uninsurable liability in the early 1990s, the sector has been on the rise again…

Vauxhall’s hushed new engines bring back company car appeal

The sound of silence is something usually reserved for the luxury end of the car market, but sat here in a Vauxhall Zafira Tourer there is an eerie lack of audio interruption. Before you think we need the tender care of…

Why the Government’s young driver Green Paper makes a lot of sense

The past few days has been a triumph and disappointment for young people as Paris Brown has gone from youth champion within the police to being investigated for some dubious tweets. It has also been a poor week for young…